US AI Hype and Sales Culture

Criticism of US AI companies for religious rhetoric, constant release cycles, gatekeeping, FUD, Altman talking about creating religion, Dario meeting Vatican, claims of building God, overzealous statements about AI capabilities

← Back to Notes on DeepSeek

Critics argue that the US AI industry has devolved into a "religious cult" characterized by toxic sales culture and messianic rhetoric from leaders like Sam Altman and Dario Amodei. While Western researchers are accused of suffering from a "psychosis" regarding AI sentience and the "singularity," China is perceived as taking a more pragmatic approach by treating the technology as a tool for infrastructure and basic needs. This American obsession with "building a God" often relies on gatekeeping and fear-mongering to maintain hype, despite the technology’s limited real-world impact outside of software development. Ultimately, these perspectives suggest that US providers have prioritized creating a brand-driven religion over delivering tangible, broadly accessible advancements.

5 comments tagged with this topic

View on HN · Topics
China is probably more capitalist in many respects than the west these days. AI, robotics and automation is a way to push into the future. In the west we have endless researchers stuck in a psychosis that they are talking to a sentient being.
View on HN · Topics
Especially here on HN, where AI anxiety (especially amongst those that are really nervous that it needs to succeed) is very, very tiresome.
View on HN · Topics
US AI is almost a religious cult. It's devastating that they are treating it as a petty commodity
View on HN · Topics
I would argue the US providers have gone full tilt into sales culture with respect to AI. Anything is said on a whim to redirect attention back from whomever is in the limelight. Initially I thought Anthropic was more pragmatic, but the constant release cycles of things that don't exist for most people, the gatekeeping, the statements made by Dario, it's all a part of large brand toxic sales and marketing. From the notes this part sat with me as the real difference: > As a whole, China seems to treat AI as just another technology, rather than as some kind of singularity moment. National attention is still on basic needs and infrastructure buildouts, and on providing more medicines for people. The “dreams of singularity" seem like a luxury or distant consideration. Meanwhile... In the fantasy land over here in the US we're constantly being told that it's "coming", "almost here", "too powerful for us to give you access to", "of national security importance!". Or... FUD. And while there may be trace amounts of truth in those overzealous statements we haven't seen a significant improvement in much outside of software development comparative to the spend and environmental impact.
View on HN · Topics
Altman used to talk about making a religion and Dario Amodei constantly talks about "building a God" and meets with religious leaders including the Vatican. > It got me thinking, though--the most successful founders do not set out to create companies. They are on a mission to create something closer to a religion, and at some point it turns out that forming a company is the easiest way to do so. [1] [1] https://blog.samaltman.com/successful-people